Final Round

Bruce Dickinson def. Rob Halford, 57% to 43%

Semi-Final Round

Rob Halford def. King Diamond, 68% to 32%
Bruce Dickinson def. Ronnie James Dio, 51% to 49%

Quarter-Final Round

King Diamond def. Ozzy Osbourne, 55% to 45%
Rob Halford def. Michael Kiske, 84% to 16%
Ronnie James Dio def. Bon Scott, 87% to 13%
Bruce Dickinson def. Ian Gillan, 79% to 21%

Fourth Round

Rob Halford def. Geoff Tate, 81% to 19%
Ozzy Osbourne def. Messiah Marcolin, 62% to 38%
Bon Scott def. Eric Adams, 55% to 45%
King Diamond def. Chuck Billy, 58% to 42%
Paul DiAnno def. Ian Gillan, 63% to 37%
Michael Kiske def. Udo Dirkschneider, 52% to 48%
Ronnie James Dio def. Robert Plant, 83% to 17%
Bruce Dickinson def. David Coverdale, 86% to 14%

Third Round

Geoff Tate def. John Bush, 61% to 39%
Robert Plant def. Jon Oliva, 61% to 39%
King Diamond def. Klaus Meine, 65% to 35%
Michael Kiske def. Mike Patton, 62% to 38%
David Coverdale def. Ralf Scheepers, 67% to 33%
Paul DiAnno def. Tim "Ripper" Owens, 52% to 48%
Rob Halford def. Bobby Ellsworth, 78% to 22%
Chuck Billy def. James Hetfield, 55% to 45%
Bon Scott def. Biff Byford, 66% to 34%
Ozzy Osbourne def. Devin Townsend, 76% to 24%
Messiah Marcolin def. Steven Tyler, 66% to 34%
Ronnie James Dio def. David Wayne, 91% to 9%
Udo Dirkschneider def. David Lee Roth, 61% to 39%
Ian Gillan def. Lemmy Kilmister, 56% to 44%
Eric Adams def. Peter Steele, 61% to 39%
Bruce Dickinson def. Phil Anselmo, 82% to 18%

Second Round

Geoff Tate def. Simone Simons, 77% to 23%
Udo Dirkschneider def. Devon Graves, 82% to 18%
Messiah Marcolin def. Alice Cooper, 54% to 46%
Paul DiAnno def. James LaBrie, 63% to 37%
Jon Oliva def. Tomi Joutsen, 74% to 26%
Biff Byford def. Eric Wagner, 62% to 38%
Devin Townsend def. David Defeis, 57% to 43%
John Bush def. Dan Swano, 73% to 27%
King Diamond def. Joey Belladonna, 68% to 32%
David Lee Roth def. Denis Belanger, 56% to 44%
Bruce Dickinson def. Alan Tecchio, 94% to 6%
Ozzy Osbourne def. Harry Conklin, 76% to 24%
Bobby Ellsworth def. Urban Breed, 87% to 13%
Ian Gillan def. Doro Pesch, 79% to 21%
Ronnie James Dio def. Sebastian Bach, 93% to 7%
Klaus Meine def. Glenn Danzig, 64% to 36%
Ralf Scheepers def. Stu Block, 57% to 43%
Bon Scott def. Chris Cornell, 72% to 28%
James Hetfield def. Robert Lowe, 63% to 37%
David Wayne def. Dee Snider, 55% to 45%
Robert Plant def. Brian Johnson, 64% to 36%
Tim "Ripper" Owens def. Lee Dorrian, 69% to 31%
Mike Patton def. Steve Grimmett, 58% to 42%
Chuck Billy def. John Arch, 72% to 28%
David Coverdale def. Hansi Kursch, 60% to 40%
Lemmy Kilmister def. Zak Stevens, 71% to 29%
Eric Adams def. Mikael Akerfeldt, 53% to 47%
Peter Steele def. Tarja Turunen, 55% to 45%
Steven Tyler def. Midnight, 51% to 49%
Phil Anselmo def. Sammy Hagar, 66% to 34%
Michael Kiske def. Warrell Dane, 55% to 45%
Rob Halford def. Russell Allen, 89% to 11%

First Round

Steve Grimmett def. Fernando Ribeiro, 57% to 43%
John Arch def. Tobias Sammett, 65% to 35%
Dan Swano def. Karyn Crisis, 73% to 27%
Tomi Joutsen def. Jorn Lande, 53% to 47%
James Hetfield def. Vintersorg, 74% to 26%
Doro Pesch def. Floor Jansen, 69% to 31%
Bobby Ellsworth def. Roy Khan, 75% to 25%
Peter Steele def. Anneke Van Giersbergen, 60% to 40%
Mikael Akerfeldt def. John Cyriis, 65% to 35%
David Defeis def. Serj Tankian, 58% to 42%
Steven Tyler def. David Draiman, 74% to 26%
Urban Breed def. Daniel Heiman, 59% to 41%
Sebastian Bach def. Layne Staley, 54% to 46%
Tarja Turunen def. Bobby Liebling, 66% to 34%
Mike Patton def. Timo Kotipelto, 68% to 32%
Brian Johnson def. Tony Moore, 71% to 29%
Robert Lowe def. Dawn Crosby, 74% to 26%
Russell Allen def. Andre Matos, 67% to 33%
Hansi Kursch def. James Rivera, 64% to 36%
Zak Stevens def. Nils K. Rue, 77% to 23%
Chuck Billy def. Mike Lezala, 91% to 9%
Eric Wagner def. Axl Rose, 55% to 45%
Stu Block def. Tim Baker, 68% to 32%
Ralf Scheepers def. Corey Taylor, 73% to 27%
Denis Belanger def. Dani Filth, 67% to 33%
Simone Simons def. Jason McMaster, 51% to 49%
Alan Tecchio def. Fabio Lione, 54% to 46%
Dee Snider def. Ray Alder, 54% to 46%
Lee Dorrian def. Phil Mogg, 52% to 48%
Paul DiAnno def. Matt Barlow, 52% to 48%
Lemmy Kilmister def. Rob Rock, 81% to 19%
Sammy Hagar def. Scott "Wino" Weinrich, 60% to 40%